Skip to main content
Back to articles
Governance, Regulation & Competitive Markets

European LPT and the Italian model:why are large Italian groups missing?

The analysis examines the main local public transport operators active in the European market, comparing their economic and operational dimensions, including turnover, number of employees, type of services operated and, in particular, their presence in foreign markets.

Share

Follow us

The lack of the formation of large national groups in the local public transport (LPT) market in Italy, unlike in other European countries, is the result of a combination of historical, regulatory and industrial factors. The main reasons behind this phenomenon can be traced to:

  • Absence of a real competitive market: Absence of a real competitive market: in many European countries, LPT has been progressively opened up to competition through periodic public tenders, with clear and time-bound tenders. This has created the conditions for the development of competitive industrial operators, driven to grow in order to acquire new contracts, also abroad. In Italy, on the contrary, the use of tenders has historically been very limited: most services have been managed by direct award or extended without competition, often through public companies controlled by local authorities.
  • Highly fragmented market structure: The Italian system has historically been characterised by hundreds of small or medium-sized operators, often locally rooted and with public governance. This fragmentation has made it difficult to form national players capable of competing with large European groups.
  • Strong roots in public-localIn Italy, most of the companies TPL has a public property local (Municipalities, Provinces or Regions), often in a logic of control and more oriented to the management of the consensus that the industrial growth.
  • Limited access to capital and delayed capitalisation: Italian LPT companies often have limited assets and reduced investment capacity. In contrast, European groups have benefited from state participations, infrastructure funds (as in the case of the Arriva group, which recently passed into the hands of the I Squared Capital fund), stock exchange listings (45% of the non-Italian operators analysed are listed on the stock exchange) or joint ventures that have allowed them to acquire companies and participate in international tenders. Without critical mass, adequate financial resources and market-oriented governance, it is difficult for an operator to develop in a multinational manner.
  • Lack of national industrial direction: Italy has lacked a systemic industrial strategy in the LPT sector, capable of stimulating integration between operators and the emergence of national champions.
CompanyCountry of originCountries of operationNo. of countriesRevenue 2023Employees 2023Services
Transdev GroupFranceFrance, Portugal, Czech Republic, Sweden, Germany, Spain, Morocco, Netherlands, Ireland, United Kingdom, Australia, New Zealand, Brazil, Chile, Colombia, Ecuador, United States and Canada19€9.33 bn105,000Bus, tram, metro, rail, ferry and funicular
RATP GroupFranceFrance, United Kingdom, Algeria, Morocco, Egypt, South Africa, Italy, Switzerland, Serbia, Belgium, Saudi Arabia, Qatar, Hong Kong, Philippines, Australia and United States16€6.152 bn71,500Bus, metro, tram, funiculars, DRT, rail, ferry and management of mobility-related services
ComfortDelGro Corporation LtdSingaporeSingapore, Australia, China, France, Ireland, Malaysia, New Zealand, Sweden, United Kingdom, Greece, Netherlands, Spain and Portugal13€3.09 bn24,500Bus, metro, tram, taxi and rail
Mobico Group PlcUnited KingdomUnited Kingdom, Spain, Germany, Portugal, Morocco, Ireland, United States, Canada, Bahrain, France, Saudi Arabia and Switzerland12€3.78 bn47,700Bus, school transport and rail
Arriva PlcUnited KingdomUnited Kingdom, Spain, Italy, Slovenia, Croatia, Hungary, Netherlands, Poland, Czech Republic, Slovakia, Hungary and Romania11€4.1 bn34,400Bus, tram, rail, ferry and DRT
Deutsche Bahn AGGermanyGermany, France, Denmark, Czech Republic, Italy, Belgium, Austria, Netherlands, Luxembourg, Poland and Switzerland11€26.181 bn219,713Bus, metro, rail, infrastructure, logistics and cargo
KeolisFranceFrance, Algeria, Belgium, Denmark, Norway, Netherlands, United Kingdom, Germany, Canada and Sweden10€7.7 bn70,000Bus, tram, DRT, school bus, bike sharing
Gruppo FS ItalianeItalyItaly, Germany, Netherlands, United Kingdom, Greece, France and Spain7€14.8 bn92,446Rail, bus, ferry, infrastructure management and cargo
Go-Ahead Group PlcUnited KingdomUnited Kingdom, Ireland, Singapore, Australia and Sweden5€3.95 bn27,000Bus, rail and tram
ATM SpAItalyItaly, Denmark, Greece and France4€982 mln10,331Bus, metro, tram, trolleybus, bike sharing and management of mobility-related services
Nobina ABSwedenSweden, Finland, Norway and Denmark4€1.21 bn12,718Bus
Stagecoach Group PlcUnited KingdomUnited Kingdom, United States and Canada3€1.65 bn24,000Bus, rail, tram and ferry
FirstGroup PlcUnited KingdomUnited Kingdom and Ireland2€5.65 bn29,000Bus, rail and tram
Basco&T Consulting elaboration on 2023 data from the operators' official websites

***Deutsche Bahn AG Group figures relate to the integrated railway system only

Italian examples of internationalization in the TPL

In the Italian panorama of public transport, FS Italiane and ATM Milano are unique examples of operators that have successfully implemented the strategies of internationalization, managing services of the TPL also outside of the national borders. The FS groupthrough its foreign subsidiaries, is present in several european Countries in particular, in Germany via Netinera, one of the leading transport operators in the local rail and road, and in the Netherlands via Qbuzzactive in many regional areas, with bus and tram.

Similarly, ATM Milano it has extended its activities in the international context, consolidating its presence in the automatic underground of Copenhagen, and the gain of the management of the metro of Thessaloniki and creating ATM Francethat was among the best in the bidders in the tender in three lots-de-l'île-de-France.

These examples demonstrate that, even in a sector that is highly localized and regulated as a TPL, Italian operators can express the skills that can be exportedseizing opportunities in foreign markets, and contributing to the construction of models of integrated mobility even outside of the national territory.

The future of the TPL in italy between races and consolidation in the industry

Even analysing the Italian cases often considered among the most efficient, it is clear how wide the distance is still compared to European best practices. The prospect of the launch of post-2026 tenders could accelerate industrial consolidation processes, favouring the entry of structured operators and encouraging dimensional growth through mergers, acquisitions or strategic partnerships. In this scenario, observing the evolution of European models may offer useful insights to anticipate competitive dynamics and define positioning strategies.

For more insights, also read our analysis of salaries in Local Public transport in Europe.

Follow us

Newsletter

Stay Updated

Subscribe to our newsletter and receive the latest reports.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime. By subscribing you accept our privacy policy.