Skip to main content
Back to articles
Public Transport Economics, Finance & Fares

Incidence of personnel costs on total production costs:a comparison of Italian LPT companies, cluster 2

The analysis is based on the incidence of personnel cost on total production costs, a relevant parameter for assessing the economic sustainability of local public transport companies. The sample considered includes 39 Italian companies, divided into three clusters based on 2023 turnover. The indicator, which averages 50.2 percent in 2023, shows variations related to organizational choices, contractual policies and different cost dynamics over time.

Share

Follow us

Non-downloadable image, to receive it please contact us at metrics@basco-t.com

The companies covered by the 2nd analysis cluster, were selected through 2023 turnover with values between or between 94 and 53 million euros. For each of them, the incidence of personnel costs on total production costs was calculated, observing the values of 2014, 2023, the average of the period 2014-2023, and the percentage change between 2023 and 2014.

Cluster 2 (ranked by personnel cost share in 2023)

No.LPT company20142023Average (2014-2023)% change 23/14
1AMAT S.p.A. (Palermo)69.7%61.8%62.2%-11.4%
2Azienda Trasporti Messina S.p.A.65.3%61.5%46.7%-5.9%
3AMTS S.p.A.59.2%59.5%60.8%0.5%
4CTM S.p.A.53.3%57.7%57.2%8.4%
5Trieste Trasporti S.p.A.55.1%53.0%53.7%-3.8%
6Arriva Udine S.r.l.54.0%52.7%50.8%-2.4%
7ASF Autolinee S.r.l.56.0%49.3%53.1%-11.9%
8TEP Parma S.p.A.45.3%46.8%45.9%3.5%
9MOM S.r.l.46.9%46.5%49.3%-0.9%
10SASA S.p.A.58.8%45.5%52.3%-22.6%
11Start Romagna S.p.A.48.7%43.9%47.2%-9.9%
12Bus Company S.r.l.44.6%43.6%42.4%-2.2%
Average54.7%51.8%-5.3%
Median54.6%51.0%-6.5%
Basco&T Consulting elaboration on data from official (non-consolidated) financial statements (AIDA database)

In 2023, the average incidence of personnel cost for Cluster 2 stands at 51.8 percent, with a median of 51 percent. Compared to 2014 (median 54.7 percent), there is an average decrease of 5.3 percentage points, while the median drops by 6.5 points. The figure suggests a general downward trend in the incidence of personnel cost on this segment of operators.

The company with the highest incidence in 2023 is AMAT S.p.A. (Palermo) with 61.8 percent, followed by AZIENDA TRASPORTI MESSINA s.p.a with 61.5 percent and AMTS s.p.a with 59.5 percent. At the opposite extreme are START ROMAGNA s.p.a with 43.9 percent and BUS COMPANY with 43.6 percent.

The greater stability in the incidence of personnel costs in Cluster 1 may depend on a more consolidated and less flexible corporate structure, with less organizational variation over time. In contrast, companies in Cluster 2, which are smaller, may have implemented reorganizations, outsourcing, or efficiency-building processes that led to a more pronounced reduction in the weight of personnel in total costs.

Also read more on Cluster 1

Follow us

Newsletter

Stay Updated

Subscribe to our newsletter and receive the latest reports.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime. By subscribing you accept our privacy policy.