[{"data":1,"prerenderedAt":-1},["ShallowReactive",2],{"mm-article:gara-tpl-regione-lazio:en:live":3},{"slug":4,"date":5,"theme":6,"featured":7,"title":8,"abstract":9,"cover":10,"coverAlt":11,"infographic":12,"infographicAlt":13,"infographicLarge":14,"infographicCount":15,"blocks":16,"metaDescription":9,"infographicFull":219,"infographics":220,"seo":223,"language":224,"unpublished":7,"related":225},"gara-tpl-regione-lazio","2026-03-16","governance-regole-mercato",false,"Lazio region public transport tender: three years after the call for tenders, only six contracts awarded","As of March 2026, the tender process for the Lazio Region’s road-based local public transport service covering eleven network units remains unfinished: five of the eleven planned lots are still awaiting award for a service that was due to commence on 1 January 2024. This is a case that warrants careful scrutiny, both from a procedural and an economic perspective.","\u002Fapi\u002Fassets\u002F10bb97c9-b826-4d62-8577-9f0dc9fefa66?width=800&format=webp","Timeline of Lazio's bus tender from 2021 to 2026 and map of the 11 lots, awarded and not; 9-year contract, 270m km, €631m","\u002Fapi\u002Fassets\u002F5e089c58-5174-44af-b121-e68793c8e4c5?width=500&format=webp","Lazio tender infographic: 11 lots with reserve prices, discounts of up to 14.8% and winners of the 6 awarded lots; 502 loaned buses out of 764 needed","\u002Fapi\u002Fassets\u002F5e089c58-5174-44af-b121-e68793c8e4c5?width=1000&format=webp",1,[17,21,24,26,28,30,32,34,36,38,133,135,137,139,141,143,145,209,211,213,215,217],{"type":18,"level":19,"text":20},"heading",2,"The procedural process: a lengthy timeline",{"type":22,"html":23},"paragraph","\u003Cp>The process leading up to the tender for the Lazio regional public transport service began in November 2021, when the Regional Executive approved, by Regional Executive Decision No. 801\u002F2021, the mandate for ASTRAL S.p.A. to manage the tender procedure. The division into eleven lots — corresponding to the identified Network Units (UdR) — was subject to public consultation between 29 December 2021 and 28 February 2022.\u003C\u002Fp>\n",{"type":22,"html":25},"\u003Cp>The framework was finalised on 29 December 2022 with the approval of the Award Report (Regional Council Decision No. 1253\u002F2022), followed by the publication of the tender notice on 13 January 2023. From that point onwards, the stages unfold with successive delays: the deadline for submitting bids, initially set for June 2023, is first pushed back to July and then to 16 October of the same year. The selection panel is formed in September, with proceedings postponed until early November.\u003C\u002Fp>\n",{"type":22,"html":27},"\u003Cp>As at 31 January 2025, the evaluation of tenders was still ongoing for several lots. The tender notice had originally specified 1 January 2024 as the start date for the new service; the updated forecast, barring further delays, indicated 1 January 2026. As of February 2026, six lots have been awarded, whilst five — Castelli Romani, Tuscia, Terra di Lavoro, Ciociaria and Sud Pontino — are still in the process of being awarded. The case of Lazio, whilst not unique on the national scene, highlights with particular clarity two structural weaknesses in the sector: the scarcity of competitive tenders and the excessive length of the selection processes. Such prolonged timelines risk rendering obsolete the economic, technical and operational assumptions on which the tender was originally based, with potentially distorting effects on the effectiveness of the contract.\u003C\u002Fp>\n",{"type":18,"level":19,"text":29},"The main features of the competition",{"type":22,"html":31},"\u003Cp>The tender is divided into eleven lots of significantly varying sizes, with annual mileage ranging from 11.2 million km for Lot 7 (Rieti) to 36.1 million km for Lot 9 (Ciociaria). Overall, over a nine-year period, the annual mileage put out to tender amounts to approximately 270 million kilometres, with a total base auction value of €630,503,635.\u003C\u002Fp>\n",{"type":22,"html":33},"\u003Cp>A key feature of the tender’s structure concerns the provision of the fleet: the 764 buses required at full capacity are not to be supplied by the successful bidders, but are to be provided by the contracting authority — ASTRAL S.p.A. — under the terms of the contract. This decision has a significant impact on the structure of the financial bid and on the level of discounts that can be achieved, as shown by the analysis below.\u003C\u002Fp>\n",{"type":22,"html":35},"\u003Cp>The base auction rates per kilometre range from €1.96 (Lot 11 – Sud Pontino) to €2.61 (Lot 4 – Castelli Romani). This difference reflects the varying operational characteristics of the lots: service frequency, network density, the topography of the area and, to some extent, the composition of the required bus fleet.\u003C\u002Fp>\n",{"type":22,"html":37},"\u003Cp>Below is a summary table of the lots with the main tender indicators.\u003C\u002Fp>\n",{"type":39,"head":40,"rows":47,"numeric":129,"rowHeads":130,"title":131,"caption":132},"table",[41,42,43,44,45,46],"Lots","Geographic area","Total km per year","Tender base (€)","Buses needed for the service","Buses provided by the contracting authority",[48,55,62,69,75,82,89,96,103,110,116,123],[49,50,51,52,53,54],"Lot 1","Tirreno Nord","30.690.171","€ 70.280.492","91","87",[56,57,58,59,60,61],"Lot 2","Valli del Tevere","24.027.510","€ 61.270.150","67","47",[63,64,65,66,67,68],"Lot 3","Valle del Sacco","26.142.640","€ 62.742.335","73","46",[70,71,72,73,74,68],"Lot 4","Castelli Romani","22.985.083","€ 59.991.067","64",[76,77,78,79,80,81],"Lot 5","Valle dell’Aniene","14.516.299","€ 34.258.466","40","16",[83,84,85,86,87,88],"Lot 6","Tuscia","20.397.123","€ 44.465.729","57","35",[90,91,92,93,94,95],"Lot 7","Reatino","11.223.418","€ 26.823.968","31","13",[97,98,99,100,101,102],"Lot 8","Terra di Lavoro","20.051.160","€ 48.724.318","56","25",[104,105,106,107,108,109],"Lot 9","Ciociaria","36.102.967","€ 90.618.447","105","71",[111,112,113,114,115,101],"Lot 10","Litorale Sud","30.189.613","€ 64.605.772","84",[117,118,119,120,121,122],"Lot 11","Sud Pontino","34.042.292","€ 66.722.892","96","60",[124,124,125,126,127,128],"","270.368.275","€ 630.503.635","764","502",[7,7,130,130,130,130],true,null,"Source: Basco&amp;T Consulting analysis of data from ASTRAL S.p.A. \u002F Lazio Region. Lots not yet awarded are highlighted in yellow.",{"type":18,"level":19,"text":134},"Economic analysis: price reductions, cost per kilometre and the impact of investment",{"type":18,"level":19,"text":136},"The discounts applied by the successful bidders",{"type":22,"html":138},"\u003Cp>In the six lots for which the outcome of the tender process is available, the discounts offered by the successful bidders range from -3.87% for Lot 3 (Valle del Sacco) to -14.83% for Lot 7 (Reatino). The average discount for the awarded lots stands at around -12.2%.\nThe total contract value for the six lots is €281,769,367, compared to a starting price of €319,981,183: an absolute discount of approximately €38,211,816. The price per kilometre resulting from the award ranges from a minimum of €1.83 (Lot 10 – Southern Coast) to a maximum of €2.31 (Lot 3 – Valle del Sacco).\u003C\u002Fp>\n",{"type":18,"level":19,"text":140},"The impact of the contracting authority’s procurement of buses",{"type":22,"html":142},"\u003Cp>Any assessment of the true cost-effectiveness of the contracts must take into account the value of the vehicle fleet. As mentioned, the tender requires ASTRAL to provide buses to operators, thereby creating a significant economic benefit. This benefit has been estimated at approximately €100 million across the entire scope of the tender, a figure calculated on the basis of the number of buses supplied by the Contracting Authority, including those already funded, multiplied by an average unit cost of approximately €200,000.\u003C\u002Fp>\n",{"type":22,"html":144},"\u003Cp>The cost per kilometre of this charge — which, under the tender structure, is not borne by the successful bidder — averages around €0.35\u002Fkm, as shown in the ‘€\u002Fkm bus (impact)’ column of the table below. This is a figure which, had it been borne by the operators, would have significantly altered the structure of the bids: the discounts observed would have been largely absorbed by the financial cost of the fleet, with the corresponding actual €\u002Fkm figures being well above those awarded.\nFor example, in Lot 10 (Southern Coast), the contract price awarded is €1.83\u002Fkm; adding the estimated depreciation cost of the fleet (€0.37\u002Fkm), the actual cost of the service to the public would be close to €2.20\u002Fkm, a figure close to the original auction base price (€2.14\u002Fkm). This order of magnitude is common to all lots and suggests that the apparent reductions do not represent an actual reduction in the public cost of the service, but rather an accounting transfer of the infrastructure burden.\u003C\u002Fp>\n",{"type":39,"head":146,"rows":153,"numeric":207,"rowHeads":130,"title":131,"caption":208},[147,148,149,150,151,152],"Lot","Area","€\u002Fkm tender base","Discount","€\u002Fkm awarded","€\u002Fkm bus (impact)",[154,160,165,171,176,182,186,192,196,199,204],[155,50,156,157,158,159],"1","2,29","-14%","1,97","0,59",[161,57,162,157,163,164],"2","2,55","2,20","0,39",[166,64,167,168,169,170],"3","2,40","-4%","2,31","0,35",[172,71,173,174,174,175],"4","2,61","–","0,40",[177,77,178,179,180,181],"5","2,36","-13%","2,06","0,22",[183,84,184,174,174,185],"6","2,18","0,34",[187,91,188,189,190,191],"7","2,39","-15%","2,04","0,23",[193,98,194,174,174,195],"8","2,43","0,25",[197,105,198,174,174,164],"9","2,51",[200,112,201,157,202,203],"10","2,14","1,83","0,37",[205,118,206,174,174,170],"11","1,96",[7,7,130,130,130,130],"Source: Basco&amp;T Consulting analysis based on data from ASTRAL S.p.A. \u002F Lazio Region. Lots not yet awarded are highlighted in yellow. €\u002Fkm bus (impact): estimated depreciation cost of the fleet supplied by ASTRAL.",{"type":18,"level":19,"text":210},"Conclusion",{"type":22,"html":212},"\u003Cp>The Lazio tender raises points for consideration in at least three areas.\u003C\u002Fp>\n",{"type":22,"html":214},"\u003Cp>From a procedural standpoint, the time taken to award the contract – over two years from the publication of the tender notice, with five lots still pending at the start of 2026 – raises questions about the contracting authorities’ ability to manage procedures of this complexity within timeframes compatible with operators’ operational planning and service scheduling.\u003C\u002Fp>\n",{"type":22,"html":216},"\u003Cp>From an economic perspective, an analysis of the bid discounts confirms that the supply of the fleet by ASTRAL represents the most significant component of the value transferred to the successful bidders. Without this intervention, significant discounts would have been unlikely: the cost of acquiring and managing hundreds of buses constitutes a significant barrier to entry, and its removal has broadened the pool of competitors.\u003C\u002Fp>\n",{"type":22,"html":218},"\u003Cp>From a transport policy perspective, the model adopted — with public infrastructure resources and private service management — is consistent with the objective of separating the ownership of networks and vehicles from their operational management. However, for this model to deliver the expected benefits in terms of efficiency and service quality, it is essential that tendering times are shortened and that contracts are launched on schedule, avoiding the risk of tacit extensions or de facto continuity with outgoing operators.\u003C\u002Fp>\n","\u002Fapi\u002Fassets\u002F5e089c58-5174-44af-b121-e68793c8e4c5",[221],{"thumb":222,"large":14,"full":219,"alt":13},"\u002Fapi\u002Fassets\u002F5e089c58-5174-44af-b121-e68793c8e4c5?width=200&format=webp",{"title":131,"description":131,"image":131,"noindex":7},"en",[226,236,246],{"slug":227,"date":228,"theme":6,"featured":7,"title":229,"abstract":230,"cover":231,"coverAlt":232,"infographic":233,"infographicAlt":234,"infographicLarge":235,"infographicCount":15},"tpl-lombardia-lazio","2026-06-18","LPT and territorial disparities: Italy’s two-speed system reflected in the tenders issued by Milan and the Lazio region","An analytical comparison of fares, mileage and investment reveals a marked imbalance between funding in the North and that in the Centre and South for local public road transport. The analysis of the structural and economic state of Local Public Transport (LPT) in Italy compares two of the most significant tendering procedures of recent years: the tender issued by the Milan, Monza and Brianza, Lodi and Pavia basin, and the Lazio Region’s combined urban and extra-urban tender managed by Astral S.p.A. The data analysed reveal a clear and unequivocal divide in terms of the public resources allocated. The data examined show a clear and unequivocal divide in terms of public resources allocated. While the Milan basinallocates €1.248 billion for a 7-year contract, ensuring a weighted average compensation of €4.17 per km (rising to €4.46 per km when including over €86 million in capital contributions exclusively intended for fleet renewal), the Lazio Region has tendered a total value of €630.5 million spread over 9 years, corresponding to a weighted average compensation of just €2.33 per km, with no structural funding flows for vehicle fleets integrated into the base contract. Beyond the purely financial gap, a deep difference also emerges in the efficiency and administrative fluidity of the two procedures (in Lazio, the tender published in 2023 has yet to complete its awarding process), confirming the existence of territorial asymmetries that disadvantage Central and Southern Italy.","\u002Fapi\u002Fassets\u002Fcd91d059-329e-475e-be48-2ff8924344ec?width=800&format=webp","Mobility Metrics cover: side-by-side maps of the public transport tenders for the Milan basin (7-year contract, 5 lots) and the Lazio region (9 years, 11 lots, only 7 awarded)","\u002Fapi\u002Fassets\u002Fb0374229-0681-4fbf-b7f3-450af0301bbf?width=500&format=webp","Infographic, Milan vs Lazio: weighted average fee of €4.17\u002Fkm against €2.33\u002Fkm, base tender value of €1.248bn against €630.5m, and no capital funding for new buses in Lazio","\u002Fapi\u002Fassets\u002Fb0374229-0681-4fbf-b7f3-450af0301bbf?width=1000&format=webp",{"slug":237,"date":238,"theme":6,"featured":7,"title":239,"abstract":240,"cover":241,"coverAlt":242,"infographic":243,"infographicAlt":244,"infographicLarge":245,"infographicCount":15},"tpl-lombardia-como-lecco-e-varese","2026-05-06","Lombardia LPT: Como, Lecco and Varese head toward tender","The new tender for local public transport in the Como–Lecco–Varese catchment area represents one of the most significant steps in the reorganisation of local public transport in Lombardy. The Catchment Area Programme provides for a total of approximately 31.68 million vehicle-kilometres per year, divided into five territorial lots: Como and the Lake, Brianza Comasca, Lecco, Varese and the Valleys, and the Varese area. Added to these is the ‘Cable Car Lot’, already awarded in 2024. Economic estimates point to a total figure of approximately €71.03 million in tender fees and €21.31 million in expected fare revenue, for a total estimated value of around €92.33 million per year. The estimated average fee is €2.24\u002Fkm, whilst average fare revenue accounts for approximately €0.67\u002Fkm, bringing the average total economic value to approximately €2.92\u002Fkm. The catchment area has a complex industrial structure: 1,343 employees in total as at 31 December 2024, of whom 1,234 are to be transferred to the new operators; a requirement for 857 buses, of which 516 are classified as essential and 215 are to be procured from scratch; and a network of 44 depots, some of which are considered essential for the continuity of the service.","\u002Fapi\u002Fassets\u002Fed0efaa6-b23d-441e-8c51-9c1ac4eee67a?width=800&format=webp","Mobility Metrics cover: map of the five lots in the Como-Lecco-Varese public transport tender (Como and Lake, Brianza Comasca, Lecco, Varese and Valleys, Varesotto), over 31.6 million vehicle-km a year","\u002Fapi\u002Fassets\u002Fe860b949-1a41-4a6b-b655-9eca08f1eb59?width=500&format=webp","Infographic on the Como-Lecco-Varese tender: 5 lots, 31.7 million km a year (22.3 million interurban), €71 million annual compensation, 1,343 staff and 857 vehicles required","\u002Fapi\u002Fassets\u002Fe860b949-1a41-4a6b-b655-9eca08f1eb59?width=1000&format=webp",{"slug":247,"date":248,"theme":6,"featured":7,"title":249,"abstract":250,"cover":251,"coverAlt":252,"infographic":253,"infographicAlt":254,"infographicLarge":255,"infographicCount":15},"tpl-lombardia-2026-gare","2026-05-04","Lombardia LPT 2026: the \"tender of tenders\"","Lombardia’s local public transport (TPL) system is heading toward a structural transformation by 2026, with the phase-out of old concessions and the introduction of a more integrated and controlled model. The system is organized into 6 Basin Agencies: the largest, Milan, Monza and Brianza, Lodi, and Pavia, covers four provinces and manages about 160 million bus-km per year, while the others cover provincial or multi-provincial areas with different territorial characteristics (mountainous, urban, or suburban).","\u002Fapi\u002Fassets\u002Fbbf8a83a-6913-4fd1-acf5-d8ecf99dfe35?width=800&format=webp","Mobility Metrics cover: map of Lombardy divided into its 6 public transport basin agencies, showing the number of lots planned for each 2026 tender","\u002Fapi\u002Fassets\u002Fbd4ff53d-f6c8-44f7-9561-b8ee95c6fd55?width=500&format=webp","Infographic on Lombardy's 2026 public transport tenders by basin: 271.8 million km a year and €665.9m in compensation; Milan-Monza-Lodi-Pavia is the largest at 158 million km and €4.14\u002Fkm","\u002Fapi\u002Fassets\u002Fbd4ff53d-f6c8-44f7-9561-b8ee95c6fd55?width=1000&format=webp"]