Skip to main content
Back to articles
Governance, Regulation & Competitive Markets

National Transport Fund disparity:between announced reforms and unchanged allocation, a transition still on hold

The distribution of the National Transport Fund (FNT) for 2018-2025 has remained essentially stable and is still based on historical criteria, despite the fact that the planned reforms have not been fully implemented. The indicators show a slight reduction in regional differences, which then stabilized, signaling that the rebalancing process is still incomplete. Without the adoption of service level indicators, the system continues to fail to reflect actual territorial needs.

Share

Follow us

The analysis examines the distribution of the National Transport Fund (FNT) among ordinary Italian regions for the period 2018-2025, analyzing the distribution of the Fund over the years and comparing per capita values with the national average. The objective is to assess whether the system is correcting historical anomalies due to outdated allocation criteria.

Sources and methodology

The sources used include ISTAT demographic data and FNT allocations published by the Ministry of Infrastructure and Transport. The methodology is based on quantitative indicators: FNT allocation, standard deviation, coefficient of variation (CV). These indicators make it possible to measure dispersion and relative equity between regions over time.

Criteria for FNT allocation: between historicity and pending reforms

Despite various regulatory revisions, the National Transport Fund allocation mechanism remains based primarily on historical criteria.

In 2023, the reforms introduced outlined a new allocation model: 50% based on standard costs, 50% on adequate service levels, with a 15% penalty for regions that do not award the service through a tender process.

Despite this, the effective application of these provisions has been postponed, pending the implementing ministerial decree expected by June 2025, which has not yet been issued.

As a result, even in 2025, the allocation was made according to historical criteria, i.e., parameters consolidated over time that allocate 90% of the fund on the basis of fixed allocation percentages; and allocating the remaining 10% again on the basis of the same percentages, but subject to verification of the achievement of specific efficiency targets.

At the same time, regions with special status and autonomous provinces are not direct beneficiaries of the National Transport Fund. They receive funding through specific mechanisms, such as extraordinary advances and contributions aimed at covering the operating deficits of local public transport. The special statutes require these entities to adapt their transport legislation in accordance with the provisions contained in the statutes themselves and in the relevant implementing regulations.

The ministerial decree that was supposed to define the indicators for adequate service levels had been postponed until June 30, 2025. As of today, November 2025, the decree has not yet been published in the Official Gazette or on the Ministry's website. The Ministry of Infrastructure and Transport confirms that the indicators are being developed but have not yet been finalized.

Consequently, the old regulatory framework will continue to apply in 2026, with the only change being the effective activation of penalties (-15%) for failure to award contracts through competitive bidding.

In summary, the allocation of the 2025 Fund followed the same procedures as in previous years, and 2026 is shaping up to be another year of transition. Regions that have not awarded services by December 31, 2025, will suffer a 15% reduction, while those that comply will benefit from redistribution.

Distribution of the FNT by region

National Transport Fund (NTF) allocation by region (thousand euros)

RegionNTF 2018NTF 2019NTF 2020NTF 2021NTF 2022NTF 2023NTF 2024NTF 2025
Lombardy855,848894,168894,168845,832863,486877,059898,639928,657
Lazio575,631601,446601,446568,329580,165594,998611,179623,500
Campania545,451570,607570,607539,709550,221547,012556,065591,722
Piedmont484,819506,621506,621478,821488,264495,145503,717525,705
Tuscany435,319455,074455,074429,021439,344445,365453,461477,174
Veneto407,511426,172426,172402,849411,697419,755427,440442,731
Apulia398,397416,942416,942394,683402,336406,604412,677427,324
Emilia-Romagna363,654380,349380,349359,106366,241380,920389,157393,515
Calabria210,004220,582220,582208,436212,887214,575217,955228,784
Liguria201,144210,278210,278198,696202,059205,032209,517218,283
Abruzzo132,717138,636138,636130,803133,824137,316139,766143,796
Marche106,981111,837111,837105,779107,935110,729112,806116,005
Umbria100,079104,626104,62698,761100,972104,225106,595108,533
Basilicata76,41579,88479,88475,48577,09778,51380,13982,860
Molise35,00336,59236,59234,57735,31536,88134,70837,956
Total4,928,9735,153,8145,153,8144,870,8874,971,8435,054,1295,153,8215,346,545
Figures in thousands of euros · Basco&T Consulting analysis based on ISTAT data and data from the Ministry of Infrastructure and Transport

Analysis of FNT data from 2018 to 2025 shows a pattern of continuity, with the allocation mechanism remaining largely unchanged despite regulatory provisions that were supposed to modify it.

The data show that, despite annual variations in the total amounts allocated (from €4.93 billion in 2018 to €5.15 billion in 2024, with a decline to €5.34 billion in 2025), regional allocations have remained largely stable, with marginal increases for some regions and reductions for others.

Measurement of inequality in the distribution of the Fund

NTF per capita by region (euros per inhabitant)

RegionPer capita 2018Per capita 2019Per capita 2020Per capita 2021Per capita 2022Per capita 2023Per capita 2024Per capita 2025Inhabitants (thousands)
Basilicata149149149149149149145145529
Umbria133133133133133133133133851
Molise121121121121121121121121287
Piedmont1141141141141141141141144,255
Calabria1121121121121121121121121,832
Apulia1071071071071071071071073,874
Tuscany1041041041041041041041043,660
Abruzzo1021031071071071071091111,268
Marche98989898989898981,481
Campania971011011011011011011015,575
Emilia-Romagna96969696969696964,465
Lombardy969696969696969610,035
Veneto96979797979797974,851
Liguria92929292929292921,509
Lazio90909090909090905,710
National average949510010097999999
Figures in thousands of euros

Standard deviation (DEV) and coefficient of variation (CV) of per-capita NTF

Year20182019202020212022202320242025
Standard deviation147123122120121121121121
Coefficient of variation34.90%28.10%27.70%27.30%27.50%27.50%27.50%27.50%
Basco&T Consulting analysis based on ISTAT data and data from the Ministry of Infrastructure and Transport

Statistical analysis of the per capita values of the National Transport Fund (FNT) between 2018 and 2025 shows a trend of progressive reduction and stabilization of distributional inequality between Italian regions.

In particular, we analyzed the standard deviation, which indicates how much the resources allocated per inhabitant differ from one another. The higher the indicator, the greater the differences between regions in the distribution of the fund.

To calculate the standard deviation, we subtracted the national average (99) from the per capita value of each region and squared the result. Finally, we took the average of these results and calculated their square root.

The result shows that, going from €147 in 2018 to around €121 in subsequent years, the system has begun to correct some of the most obvious historical distortions but at the same time has stabilized.

We then analyzed the coefficient of variation (CV), calculated as the ratio between standard deviation and per capita average, to understand how uniform the distribution of the fund is among the regions. A low coefficient indicates that the regions receive similar values, while a high coefficient indicates an unbalanced distribution.

Also in this case, we can see a stabilization of values from 2022 onwards, although they remain above the 10% threshold considered indicative of fair distribution, indicating that the rebalancing process is still incomplete.

The stabilization of values reflects a phase of consolidation, but also a certain inertia in the system, which continues to be based on historical criteria pending the full implementation of the planned reforms.

In summary, the data show a measurable improvement in distributive equity, but confirm the need to definitively move beyond the model based on historical expenditure and adopt an approach based on real needs and service levels.

Resource allocation: comparison between regions and per capita averages

NTF per capita 2025 and deviation from the national average

RegionPer capita 2025DEV 2025
Basilicata14546
Umbria13334
Molise12122
Piedmont11415
Calabria11213
Apulia1078
Tuscany1045
Abruzzo11112
Marche98-1
Campania1012
Emilia-Romagna96-3
Lombardy96-3
Veneto97-2
Liguria92-7
Lazio90-9
Figures expressed in euros per inhabitant · Basco&T Consulting analysis based on ISTAT data and data from the Ministry of Infrastructure and Transport

A further level of analysis, based on deviation from the per capita average, confirms and deepens the picture of inequality.

The deviation, calculated as the difference between the per capita value of each region and the national average, indicates whether a region receives more or less resources than the national average (equal to 99).

A positive deviation indicates that the region is receiving more resources than the national average, while a negative deviation shows below-average funding.

Some regions continue to receive resources above the national average per capita: Basilicata, for example, has a positive deviation of €46 per capita, followed by Umbria with €34 and Molise with €22.

These figures indicate greater spending capacity for local public transport, which could potentially translate into more frequent or more accessible services.

Conversely, regions such as Lazio and Liguria receive less than the per capita average, with negative deviations of €9 and €7 per capita, respectively. These differences may be reflected in a lower capacity to invest in local public transport, with possible repercussions on service quality, territorial coverage, and the economic sustainability of local networks.

Conclusion

The analysis shows that, between 2018 and 2025, the distribution of the National Transport Fund followed historical criteria, with limited effects on reducing regional inequalities.

The planned reforms have not been fully implemented, and penalties for failure to allocate funds have not been applied. Without the adoption of service indicators, the distribution remains unchanged.

The picture confirms the need for structural change to ensure distribution that is more in line with actual needs.

Follow us

Newsletter

Stay Updated

Subscribe to our newsletter and receive the latest reports.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime. By subscribing you accept our privacy policy.