Skip to main content
Back to articles
Public Transport Economics, Finance & Fares

Share of cost items in LPT:an analysis of 39 Italian companies, cluster 1

The analysis looks at the share of each cost item in total production costs, a key parameter for assessing the economic sustainability of local public transport companies. The sample covers 39 Italian companies, divided into three clusters by 2023 turnover.

Share

Follow us

For each company in the cluster, the table shows the percentage share of each cost item in total production costs for 2014 and 2023, the average for 2014-2023 and the percentage change between 2014 and 2023. Figures are percentages, sorted by 2023 turnover in descending order.

For AMT S.p.a., the table shows total production costs for 2019, the average for 2014-2019 and the percentage change between 2014 and 2019.

The first cluster, shown below, includes the 15 Italian LPT companies with the highest turnover, between €980 million and €95 million.

Personnel costs

Personnel costs as a share of total production costs

No.LPT company2023Average (2014-2023)Change % 23/14
1ATM S.p.A. (Milan)47.8%41.4%-9.2%
2ATAC S.p.A. (Rome)51.7%52.6%15.4%
3Autolinee Toscane S.p.A.50.1%43.7%11.5%
4GTT S.p.A.47.1%47.4%-6.7%
5COTRAL S.p.A.44.1%48.6%-9.1%
6AMT S.p.A.*59.6%59.6%-0.1%
7TPER S.p.A.43.4%45.1%-3.7%
8ANM S.p.A. (Naples)51.4%54.3%-9.9%
9Arriva Italia S.r.l.41.8%51.5%-21.0%
10TUA S.p.A.50.3%52.6%-0.8%
11Trentino Trasporti S.p.A.54.9%46.5%-3.7%
12Busitalia53.1%51.7%27.0%
13SETA S.p.A.40.4%41.7%-5.9%
14Autoguidovie S.p.A.42.4%45.0%-0.7%
15Air Campania52.8%51.9%-3.0%
Average48.7%-1.3%
Median50.1%-3.7%
Basco&T Consulting analysis of data from official financial statements (AIDA)

*AMT S.P.A data refer to 2019

In 2023, personnel costs accounted on average for 48.7% of production costs, slightly down on 2014 (-1.3%). Arriva Italia shows the largest drop in share; some companies are almost unchanged, such as Autoguidovie (-0.7%) and TUA S.p.a. (-0.8%); others show significant changes: ATAC grew by 15.4% and Busitalia by 27.0%.

Cost of services

Cost of services as a share of total production costs

No.LPT company2023Average (2014-2023)Change % 23/14
1ATM S.p.A. (Milan)30.8%28.5%-8.7%
2ATAC S.p.A. (Rome)23.1%20.4%20.2%
3Autolinee Toscane S.p.A.23.4%30.1%8.1%
4GTT S.p.A.22.3%21.3%3.5%
5COTRAL S.p.A.20.2%20.6%2.6%
6AMT S.p.A.*15.5%1.1%6.5%
7TPER S.p.A.27.0%27.4%-7.0%
8ANM S.p.A. (Naples)25.0%24.0%7.1%
9Arriva Italia S.r.l.27.4%26.2%-16.6%
10TUA S.p.A.16.9%16.3%5.1%
11Trentino Trasporti S.p.A.26.6%28.1%-16.8%
12Busitalia23.8%23.6%-26.5%
13SETA S.p.A.33.8%31.3%18.3%
14Autoguidovie S.p.A.22.8%21.4%3.4%
15Air Campania20.4%19.7%29.8%
Average23.9%1.9%
Median23.4%3.5%
Basco&T Consulting analysis of data from official financial statements (AIDA)

*AMT S.P.A data refer to 2019

In 2023, the cost of services accounted on average for 23.9% of production costs, with a median of 23.4%. The average change over 2014-2023 is limited (1.9%), but with significant differences between companies.

Some operators show a sharp increase, such as Air Campania (+29.8%) and ATAC S.p.A. (+20.2%). By contrast, there are marked falls for Busitalia (-26.5%), Trentino Trasporti (-16.8%) and Arriva Italia (-16.6%).

COTRAL S.P.A, Autoguidovie e GTT S.P.A. si mantengono sostanzialmente stabili, mentre Autolinee Toscane e TUA S.p.A. evidenziano variazioni moderate.

Materie prime e consumi

Raw materials as a share of total production costs

No.LPT company2023Average (2014-2023)Change % 23/14
1ATM S.p.A. (Milan)7.4%10.2%-57.8%
2ATAC S.p.A. (Rome)9.6%8.5%30.4%
3Autolinee Toscane S.p.A.16.8%15.4%-22.8%
4GTT S.p.A.9.5%9.3%-8.4%
5COTRAL S.p.A.15.0%17.6%-33.9%
6AMT S.p.A.*11.8%11.8%-10.4%
7TPER S.p.A.16.4%13.8%17.7%
8ANM S.p.A. (Naples)13.0%9.5%32.6%
9Arriva Italia S.r.l.17.0%6.9%27.6%
10TUA S.p.A.17.0%16.2%-13.5%
11Trentino Trasporti S.p.A.15.5%12.7%87.7%
12Busitalia12.8%11.8%-20.9%
13SETA S.p.A.14.4%14.4%-7.2%
14Autoguidovie S.p.A.16.8%16.0%-3.2%
15Air Campania16.5%17.5%-20.1%
Average14.0%-0.2%
Median15.0%-8.4%
Basco&T Consulting analysis of data from official financial statements (AIDA)

*AMT S.P.A data refer to 2019

In 2023, raw materials accounted on average for 14.0% of production costs, with a median of 15.0%. Over 2014-2023 the picture is broadly stable (average -0.2%), with a negative change of -8.4% in the median.

The sharpest fall is at ATM S.p.A. (-57.8%), followed by Cotral and Autolinee Toscane, both down by more than 20%. By contrast, Trentino Trasporti shows the largest increase (87.7%), followed by ANM S.p.A. (32.6%) and ATAC S.p.A. (30.4%).

These changes may partly reflect more efficient consumption, fleet efficiency improvements, and the effect of energy prices and purchasing policies.

Ammortamenti

Depreciation as a share of total production costs

No.LPT company2023Average (2014-2023)Change % 23/14
1ATM S.p.A. (Milan)12.6%14.7%-25.2%
2ATAC S.p.A. (Rome)6.5%7.4%-23.8%
3Autolinee Toscane S.p.A.4.0%6.7%-58.1%
4GTT S.p.A.9.6%10.4%21.7%
5COTRAL S.p.A.5.8%3.5%349.2%
6AMT S.p.A.*6.9%6.9%-7.0%
7TPER S.p.A.7.6%6.3%48.4%
8ANM S.p.A. (Naples)2.4%2.6%-34.1%
9Arriva Italia S.r.l.7.5%8.7%8.1%
10TUA S.p.A.9.0%9.8%-10.8%
11Trentino Trasporti S.p.A.1.5%10.0%-92.9%
12Busitalia7.7%7.0%82.8%
13SETA S.p.A.8.6%8.5%4.8%
14Autoguidovie S.p.A.8.2%6.0%174.7%
15Air Campania4.4%3.1%-4.1%
Average6.8%28.9%
Median7.5%-4.1%
Basco&T Consulting analysis of data from official financial statements (AIDA)

*AMT S.P.A data refer to 2019

In 2023, depreciation accounted on average for 6.8% of total production costs, with a median of 7.5%. The average change over 2014-2023 is 28.9%, while the median shows a decrease (-4.1%).

The sharpest falls are at Trentino Trasporti (-92.9%) and Autolinee Toscane (-58.1%), while Cotral (+349.2%), Autoguidovie (+174.7%) and Busitalia (+82.8%) show significant increases.

Leases and rentals

Leases and rentals as a share of total production costs

No.LPT company2023Average (2014-2023)Change % 23/14
1ATM S.p.A. (Milan)0.3%0.5%-63.2%
2ATAC S.p.A. (Rome)2.7%2.2%43.6%
3Autolinee Toscane S.p.A.2.9%1.4%35.5%
4GTT S.p.A.9.8%8.7%27.3%
5COTRAL S.p.A.6.0%3.2%31.2%
6AMT S.p.A.*1.1%1.1%5.8%
7TPER S.p.A.1.1%3.0%-51.8%
8ANM S.p.A. (Naples)2.7%2.8%3.0%
9Arriva Italia S.r.l.2.2%3.1%-45.9%
10TUA S.p.A.1.1%1.1%-40.1%
11Trentino Trasporti S.p.A.0.3%0.3%-52.6%
12Busitalia0.9%1.6%-4.8%
13SETA S.p.A.1.6%1.7%-2.2%
14Autoguidovie S.p.A.6.9%9.6%-44.0%
15Air Campania3.3%5.1%15.9%
Average2.9%-9.5%
Median2.2%-2.2%
Basco&T Consulting analysis of data from official financial statements (AIDA)

*AMT S.P.A data refer to 2019

In 2023, leases and rentals accounted on average for 2.9% of production costs, with a median of 2.2%, slightly down on the past (-9.5% on average), but with different trends across companies.

Trentino Trasporti, Autoguidovie and TUA S.p.A. sharply reduced this item, but ATM S.p.A. (Milan) shows the steepest fall (-63.2%). Conversely, ATAC S.p.A. and Autolinee Toscane show significant increases (+43.6% and +35.5% respectively). Cotral and GTT are also above their historical average.

Other costs and operating charges

Other costs as a share of total production costs

No.LPT company2023Average (2014-2023)Change % 23/14
1ATM S.p.A. (Milan)0.3%3.2%-92.0%
2ATAC S.p.A. (Rome)4.2%6.7%-74.8%
3Autolinee Toscane S.p.A.1.9%1.6%-8.0%
4GTT S.p.A.0.3%1.6%-69.3%
5COTRAL S.p.A.7.9%4.8%463.2%
6AMT S.p.A.*3.9%3.9%29.2%
7TPER S.p.A.2.8%3.0%-27.2%
8ANM S.p.A. (Naples)3.1%5.3%30.3%
9Arriva Italia S.r.l.2.0%1.2%
10TUA S.p.A.4.0%2.0%484.8%
11Trentino Trasporti S.p.A.0.1%0.5%-80.9%
12Busitalia - Sita Nord S.r.l.0.0%1.6%
13SETA S.p.A.0.2%1.4%-89.3%
14Autoguidovie S.p.A.1.4%0.6%110.7%
15Air Campania0.2%0.6%
Average2.2%56.4%
Median1.9%-17.6%
Basco&T Consulting analysis of data from official financial statements (AIDA)

*AMT S.P.A data refer to 2019

In 2023, other costs accounted for an average of 2.2% and a median of 1.9%, down on the 2014-2023 median (-17.6%). However, there are marked differences between companies:

  • ATM S.p.A. (-92.0%) and SETA S.p.a. (-89.3%) are among the sharpest falls.
  • TUA (+484,8%), COTRAL (+463,2%) e Autoguidovie (+110,7%) registrano forti incrementi.

Operating charges as a share of total production costs

No.LPT company2023AverageChange % 23/14
1ATM S.p.A. (Milan)0.9%1.4%-29.5%
2ATAC S.p.A. (Rome)2.1%2.4%55.0%
3Autolinee Toscane S.p.A.1.0%1.0%529.1%
4GTT S.p.A.1.4%1.3%36.8%
5COTRAL S.p.A.1.1%1.6%-41.8%
6AMT S.p.A.*1.1%1.1%9.4%
7TPER S.p.A.1.7%1.3%158.3%
8ANM S.p.A. (Naples)2.4%1.5%108.1%
9Arriva Italia S.r.l.2.1%2.4%-17.8%
10TUA S.p.A.1.7%2.0%74.1%
11Trentino Trasporti S.p.A.1.0%1.8%-81.6%
12Busitalia - Sita Nord S.r.l.1.6%2.7%-60.3%
13SETA S.p.A.1.0%1.0%-28.3%
14Autoguidovie S.p.A.1.5%1.4%-20.9%
15Air Campania2.0%2.1%21.9%
Average1.5%47.5%
Median1.5%9.4%
Basco&T Consulting analysis of data from official financial statements (AIDA)

*AMT S.P.A data refer to 2019

In 2023, operating charges stood at an average and median of 1.5%, with varying trends:

  • In forte crescita troviamo Autolinee Toscane (+529,1%), seguita da TPER (+158,3%) e ANM S.p.a. (Napoli) (108,1%)
  • The largest falls include Busitalia (-60.3%), followed by Cotral (-41.8%), ATM Milano (-29.5%) and SETA S.P.A (-28.3%).

These costs often reflect management, organisational or accounting choices.

Follow us

Newsletter

Stay Updated

Subscribe to our newsletter and receive the latest reports.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime. By subscribing you accept our privacy policy.