---
title: "Is hydrogen really a sustainable alternative for public transport? | Basco&T"
description: "Hydrogen is back at the centre of the global energy debate. The reason for this renewed interest is that hydrogen, which produces only water, is seen as the definitive solution for replacing fossil fuels. Hydrogen is produced from renewable sources and…"
canonical_url: "https://www.basco-t.com/en/insights/l-alternativa-dell-idrogeno-nel-trasporto-pubblico-e-davvero-sostenibile"
locale: en
meta:
  "og:description": "Hydrogen is back at the centre of the global energy debate. The reason for this renewed interest is that hydrogen, which produces only water, is seen as the definitive solution for replacing fossil fuels. Hydrogen is produced from renewable sources and…"
  "og:image": "https://www.basco-t.com/api/assets/758ed319-36f2-4869-bc8b-219b24072253?width=1200&height=630&fit=cover&format=jpg&quality=80"
  "og:image:alt": "City bus with \"Hydrogen powered\" livery in an urban setting, with the title of the study on hydrogen bus TCO compared with per-kilometre fees"
  "og:title": "Is hydrogen really a sustainable alternative for public transport? | Basco&T"
  "twitter:description": "Hydrogen is back at the centre of the global energy debate. The reason for this renewed interest is that hydrogen, which produces only water, is seen as the definitive solution for replacing fossil fuels. Hydrogen is produced from renewable sources and…"
  "twitter:image:alt": "City bus with \"Hydrogen powered\" livery in an urban setting, with the title of the study on hydrogen bus TCO compared with per-kilometre fees"
  "twitter:title": "Is hydrogen really a sustainable alternative for public transport? | Basco&T"
---

> Index of every page on this site: [llms.txt](https://www.basco-t.com/llms.txt)

[←** All insights**](https://www.basco-t.com/en/insights)**23 February 2023**

# **Is hydrogen really a sustainable alternative for public transport?**

Hydrogen is back at the centre of the global energy debate. The reason for this renewed interest is that hydrogen, which produces only water, is seen as the definitive solution for replacing fossil fuels. Hydrogen is produced from renewable sources and…

![City bus with "Hydrogen powered" livery in an urban setting, with the title of the study on hydrogen bus TCO compared with per-kilometre fees](https://www.basco-t.com/api/assets/758ed319-36f2-4869-bc8b-219b24072253)

## Assessing the Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) and comparing it with per-kilometre service payments

Hydrogen is back at the centre of the global energy debate. The reason for this renewed interest is that hydrogen, which produces only water, is seen as the definitive solution for replacing fossil fuels.

Hydrogen is produced from renewable sources and can be stored and converted into electricity.

> The transport sector is the hardest to decarbonise.

To date, efforts on hydrogen have focused on the use of the *fuel cell*, an electrochemical device that directly converts the chemical energy of the fuel (water) into electricity without any thermal combustion process (*GREEN-Università Bocconi &Enel Foundation, 2021).*

Hydrogen-powered buses using *fuel cell* technology, especially in urban transport, have been trialled on roads all over the world, including in Italy: in Turin, Bolzano, Trento and Milan, since the early 2000s.

All these projects have contributed to the spread of hydrogen in Europe, led by Germany.

Although hydrogen-powered vehicles, like those running on electricity, are incentivised by European regulations, the latter are considered competitors to internal combustion vehicles, whereas the same cannot be said of hydrogen-powered buses.

## The costs of hydrogen

Hydrogen (H2) on its own is very rare in nature, but it is abundant in organic and inorganic compounds, such as methane (CH4) or water (H2O), from which it can be separated in gaseous form.

> Indeed, grey hydrogen has to be produced, and producing it still requires more energy than can be obtained from it.

For this reason, conventional grey hydrogen is of little interest for the green energy transition.

Experts instead urge governments to invest in **blue hydrogen** **and above all in green hydrogen**, which differ mainly in their extraction methods and technologies. **Blue hydrogen** is **obtained from fossil hydrocarbons** in dedicated plants, while **green hydrogen** is the best in terms of environmental sustainability because it **is extracted from water using electricity generated by renewable energy plants**.

## Vehicle cost and service life

The current costs of hydrogen buses can be inferred from recent deliveries in several cities. In general, based on a study conducted by Università Bocconi in collaboration with Enel Foundation, we can estimate a market value of around €670,000 for a new 12 m hydrogen bus. This figure is set to fall in the coming years, with a projected decrease of 43% by 2030 compared with 2021 prices.

**Average purchase price of a 12 m hydrogen bus**

Thousands of euros and reduction compared with 2021

Average purchase price (€ thousand)% reduction

202120252030

Average purchase price of a 12 m hydrogen bus

|  | Average purchase price (€ thousand) | % reduction |
| --- | --- | --- |
| 2021 | 670 € | 0 % |
| 2025 | 480 € | -28 % |
| 2030 | 380 € | -43 % |

*Data source: GREEN-Università Bocconi & Enel Foundation. (2021). «Scenari e prospettive dell’elettrificazione del trasporto pubblico su strada - Un’innovativa analisi di benchmark: Il TCRO - Total Cost and Revenues of Ownership» (Scenarios and prospects for the electrification of road public transport). Analysis by Basco&T Consulting®*

The average service life of hydrogen buses is about the same number of years as that of diesel vehicles. The service life of electric buses is noticeably shorter than that of hydrogen buses because the battery needs revamping after about 7-8 years.

**Average vehicle service life by fuel type**

2021-2030

Vehicle service lifeWith revamping

**Electric**

8 years

15 years

**Diesel**

10 years

14 years

**CNG**

10 years

14 years

**Hydrogen**

10 years

14 years

Average vehicle service life by fuel type

|  | Vehicle service life | With revamping |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Electric | 8 years | 15 years |
| Diesel | 10 years | 14 years |
| CNG | 10 years | 14 years |
| Hydrogen | 10 years | 14 years |

*Note: average values, based on the vehicle usage beyond which maintenance costs increase. Data source: GREEN-Università Bocconi & Enel Foundation. (2021). «Scenari e prospettive dell’elettrificazione del trasporto pubblico su strada - Un’innovativa analisi di benchmark: Il TCRO - Total Cost and Revenues of Ownership» (Scenarios and prospects for the electrification of road public transport). Analysis by Basco&T Consulting®*

## Operating costs

Estimates of operating costs from the study by Università Bocconi and Enel Foundation, based on average consumption data (approximately 12.5 km per kg of hydrogen at a cost of €10/kg), give a traction cost of approximately €0.8/km. A decrease is expected in the coming years thanks to the greater efficiency and technology of new buses, both in terms of production and in the storage and distribution of hydrogen.

Maintenance costs of €0.27/km have been assumed to remain constant in the coming years: the expected improvements, and the resulting cost reductions, relate to the entire production, storage, transport and distribution system, rather than specifically to maintaining the operational efficiency of the vehicles.

**Traction cost of a hydrogen bus**

€/km and reduction compared with 2021

Hydrogen consumption cost (€/km)% reduction

202120252030

Traction cost of a hydrogen bus

|  | Hydrogen consumption cost (€/km) | % reduction |
| --- | --- | --- |
| 2021 | 0.8 €/km | 0 % |
| 2025 | 0.72 €/km | -10 % |
| 2030 | 0.54 €/km | -33 % |

*Data source: GREEN-Università Bocconi & Enel Foundation. (2021). «Scenari e prospettive dell’elettrificazione del trasporto pubblico su strada - Un’innovativa analisi di benchmark: Il TCRO - Total Cost and Revenues of Ownership» (Scenarios and prospects for the electrification of road public transport). Analysis by Basco&T Consulting®*

## The cost of infrastructure

The average cost of a refuelling station able to serve around 25 buses a day could be in the region of €5 million, based on market values, a figure in line with the provisions of the PNRR (National Recovery and Resilience Plan) for building 40 stations by 2026.

Transporting hydrogen is particularly difficult because of the extremely small size of hydrogen molecules, which increases the risk of leakage. For this reason, the vast majority of hydrogen is produced locally.

## TCO analysis: how much does it cost to run a hydrogen bus?

To analyse the costs of running a hydrogen-powered public transport vehicle, the Basco&T Consulting team of experts focused on providing a per-km cost comparison of purchase, maintenance, energy consumption, staff, other operating costs and infrastructure for the different types of bus currently in Italy's public fleet.

## Hydrogen in public transport: the inadequacy of service payments

**TCO €/km (12 m bus) – 2021**

| **Electric** | 0.64 | 0.16 | 0.27 | 0.05 | **1.12** |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| **Diesel** | 0.33 | 0.28 | 0.34 | 0.003 | **0.95** |
| **CNG** | 0.34 | 0.31 | 0.29 | 0.01 | **0.95** |
| **Hydrogen** | 0.92 | 0.27 | 0.80 | 0.13 | **2.12** |

TCO €/km (12 m bus) – 2021

*Data source: GREEN-Università Bocconi & Enel Foundation. (2021). «Scenari e prospettive dell’elettrificazione del trasporto pubblico su strada - Un’innovativa analisi di benchmark: Il TCRO - Total Cost and Revenues of Ownership» (Scenarios and prospects for the electrification of road public transport). Analysis by Basco&T Consulting®*

The analysis shows that *full electric* vehicles are more competitive than diesel and CNG in terms of energy consumption. As for hydrogen, the cost of energy consumption currently weighs heavily on the total cost per km.

**Costs in €/km by fuel type – 12 m bus**

Average values

PurchaseMaintenanceConsumptionInfrastructureStaffOther operating costsAverage service payment (€/km)

DieselCNGElectric**Hydrogen**

Costs in €/km by fuel type – 12 m bus

|  | Purchase | Maintenance | Consumption | Infrastructure | Staff | Other operating costs | Totale |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Diesel | 0.33 | 0.28 | 0.34 | 0 | 1.3 | 0.2 | 2.45 |
| CNG | 0.34 | 0.31 | 0.29 | 0.01 | 1.3 | 0.2 | 2.45 |
| Electric | 0.64 | 0.16 | 0.27 | 0.05 | 1.3 | 0.2 | 2.62 |
| Hydrogen | 0.92 | 0.27 | 0.8 | 0.13 | 1.3 | 0.2 | 3.62 |

*Data source: GREEN-Università Bocconi & Enel Foundation. (2021). «Scenari e prospettive dell’elettrificazione del trasporto pubblico su strada - Un’innovativa analisi di benchmark: Il TCRO - Total Cost and Revenues of Ownership» (Scenarios and prospects for the electrification of road public transport). Processing and analysis by Basco&T Consulting®*

**€/km (12 m bus) – 2021**

Total cost by fuel type and difference from the current average service payment of €2.59/km

| **Diesel** | 0.33 | 0.28 | 0.34 | 0.003 | 1.30 | 0.2 | **2.45** | 0.14 |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| **CNG** | 0.34 | 0.31 | 0.29 | 0.01 | 1.30 | 0.2 | **2.45** | 0.14 |
| **Electric** | 0.64 | 0.16 | 0.27 | 0.05 | 1.30 | 0.2 | **2.62** | -0.03 |
| **Hydrogen** | 0.92 | 0.27 | 0.80 | 0.13 | 1.30 | 0.2 | **3.62** | -1.03 |

€/km (12 m bus) – 2021

*Data source: GREEN-Università Bocconi & Enel Foundation. (2021). «Scenari e prospettive dell’elettrificazione del trasporto pubblico su strada - Un’innovativa analisi di benchmark: Il TCRO - Total Cost and Revenues of Ownership» (Scenarios and prospects for the electrification of road public transport). Processing and analysis by Basco&T Consulting®*

**Average service payment by geographical area**

€/km

Northern Italy

€2.68**Central Italy**

**€3.02**Southern Italy

€2.13

Average service payment by geographical area

|  | Valore |
| --- | --- |
| Northern Italy | €2.68 |
| Central Italy | €3.02 |
| Southern Italy | €2.13 |

*Data and analysis by Basco&T Consulting®*

Considering staff costs and other operating costs per km estimated by Basco&T Consulting's experts, the €/km cost borne by public transport companies to operate hydrogen vehicles is significantly higher than current average Italian service payments. In fact, the average Italian service payment, taking into account average service payments in the regions of northern, central and southern Italy, stands at €2.59/km.

> It is therefore clear that the current average service payments granted to public transport companies are insufficient to cover the costs of operating a hydrogen fleet.

In general, then, comparing zero-emission vehicles, we can conclude that:

**Full electric and hydrogen: advantages and disadvantages**

**Full electric**

**Hydrogen**

**Advantages**

Lower maintenance and operating costs;

Battery costs falling in the coming years;

The vehicle’s service life can be extended by replacing its batteries at the end of their life.

Engine maintenance costs are lower than for combustion engines. On the other hand, specific maintenance of the hydrogen tanks is essential because of hydrogen’s characteristics.

**Disadvantages**

Initial investment cost still particularly high today, and the vehicle or battery needs replacing after about 8 years;

Investment needed in depot charging infrastructure and in opportunity-charging infrastructure for the longer routes;

Public transport routes and services have to be reshaped around the charging needs, times and methods of electric vehicles.

High initial investment costs, given that the technology is still immature;

Limited number of manufacturers and models;

High operating costs;

Maintenance is highly technology-intensive;

Very high cost of refuelling infrastructure.

**Data source: GREEN-Università Bocconi & Enel Foundation. (2021). «Scenari e prospettive dell’elettrificazione del trasporto pubblico su strada - Un’innovativa analisi di benchmark: Il TCRO - Total Cost and Revenues of Ownership» (Scenarios and prospects for the electrification of road public transport). Analysis by Basco&T Consulting®**

In recent years, local, national and international bodies have repeatedly spoken out, through numerous initiatives, on the need to decarbonise the transport sector, starting with public transport.

The shift of local public transport companies towards hydrogen powertrains is supported mainly by the PNRR, which has launched trials of hydrogen use in road transport. These trials, the subject of a decree by Minister Giovannini, set out how to implement the investments, which amount to €230 million. The aim is to develop hydrogen trials by building at least 40 refuelling stations for light and heavy vehicles by 30 June 2026. When locating the refuelling stations, priority is given to areas of strategic importance for heavy road transport, such as areas close to inland terminals, the routes most used by long-haul freight vehicles, and connections to local public transport systems using hydrogen-powered vehicles.

In addition, the PNRR has allocated €1.9 billion for the purchase of electric and hydrogen buses in large municipalities.

Today's landscape, however, shows a **growing shift towards electric power, in public transport too, rather than towards hydrogen, which is still at the trial stage.**

It is clear that administrations and public bodies intend to focus on electric and hydrogen power in the coming years, but **are the service payments received by public transport companies really sufficient to cover the operating costs of running this type of vehicle?**

Analyses carried out by Basco&T Consulting show that the conversion of the Italian fleet to electric buses is now well established: the operating costs of a service run with full electric vehicles are at least partially sustainable with current service payments.

> As far as hydrogen is concerned, operating and investment costs are still so high that they far exceed the average service payments due to Italian public transport companies.

It can be said that **the transport sector is currently in a phase of transition and continuous change**, with technologies advancing at an unprecedented pace. However, the boost from funding is not enough to persuade local public transport companies to switch to hydrogen. Experimental hydrogen refuelling stations will probably help reduce infrastructure-related operating and investment costs from 2026 onwards.

**The transition the transport sector is going through today**, driven first and foremost by rising traction costs and then by the shift towards renewable energy sources, **will also be reflected in the renegotiation of service payments, which in many cases are currently insufficient to cover the operating costs of the service.**

> Data source: GREEN-Università Bocconi & Enel Foundation. (2021). «Scenari e prospettive dell’elettrificazione del trasporto pubblico su strada – Un’innovativa analisi di benchmark: Il TCRO – Total Cost and Revenues of Ownership» (Scenarios and prospects for the electrification of road public transport – An innovative benchmark analysis: TCRO – Total Cost and Revenues of Ownership).

## **Want to know more?**

For more information and further insight on this topic, write to us and we will get back to you shortly.

[**Contact Us **](https://www.basco-t.com/en/contatti)

```json
{"@context":"https://schema.org","@graph":[{"@id":"https://www.basco-t.com/en#website","@type":"WebSite","inLanguage":"en-GB","name":"Basco&T","url":"https://www.basco-t.com/en","publisher":{"@id":"https://www.basco-t.com/#identity"},"translationOfWork":{"@id":"https://www.basco-t.com/it#website"}},{"@id":"https://www.basco-t.com/en/insights/l-alternativa-dell-idrogeno-nel-trasporto-pubblico-e-davvero-sostenibile#webpage","@type":"WebPage","datePublished":"2023-02-23","description":"Hydrogen is back at the centre of the global energy debate. The reason for this renewed interest is that hydrogen, which produces only water, is seen as the definitive solution for replacing fossil fuels. Hydrogen is produced from renewable sources and…","name":"Is hydrogen really a sustainable alternative for public transport? | Basco&T","url":"https://www.basco-t.com/en/insights/l-alternativa-dell-idrogeno-nel-trasporto-pubblico-e-davvero-sostenibile","isPartOf":{"@id":"https://www.basco-t.com/en#website"},"potentialAction":[{"@type":"ReadAction","target":["https://www.basco-t.com/en/insights/l-alternativa-dell-idrogeno-nel-trasporto-pubblico-e-davvero-sostenibile"]}],"primaryImageOfPage":{"@id":"https://www.basco-t.com/#logo"}},{"@id":"https://www.basco-t.com/#identity","@type":"Organization","name":"Basco&T","url":"https://www.basco-t.com","logo":{"@id":"https://www.basco-t.com/#logo"},"sameAs":["https://www.linkedin.com/company/basco-t/","https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=61573738169898","https://www.instagram.com/mobility_metrics/"]},{"@id":"https://www.basco-t.com/en/insights/l-alternativa-dell-idrogeno-nel-trasporto-pubblico-e-davvero-sostenibile#article","@type":"Article","datePublished":"2023-02-23","description":"Hydrogen is back at the centre of the global energy debate. The reason for this renewed interest is that hydrogen, which produces only water, is seen as the definitive solution for replacing fossil fuels. Hydrogen is produced from renewable sources and…","headline":"Is hydrogen really a sustainable alternative for public transport?","inLanguage":"en-GB","thumbnailUrl":"https://www.basco-t.com/api/assets/758ed319-36f2-4869-bc8b-219b24072253","author":{"@id":"https://www.basco-t.com/#/schema/person/1"},"image":{"@id":"https://www.basco-t.com/#/schema/image/1"},"isPartOf":{"@id":"https://www.basco-t.com/en/insights/l-alternativa-dell-idrogeno-nel-trasporto-pubblico-e-davvero-sostenibile#webpage"},"mainEntityOfPage":{"@id":"https://www.basco-t.com/en/insights/l-alternativa-dell-idrogeno-nel-trasporto-pubblico-e-davvero-sostenibile#webpage"},"publisher":{"@id":"https://www.basco-t.com/#identity"}},{"@id":"https://www.basco-t.com/#/schema/person/1","@type":"Person","name":"Edoardo Tartaglia","url":"https://www.linkedin.com/in/edoardo-tartaglia/"},{"@id":"https://www.basco-t.com/#logo","@type":"ImageObject","caption":"Basco&T","contentUrl":"https://www.basco-t.com/logos/Logo Sfondo Bianco.png","inLanguage":"en-GB","url":"https://www.basco-t.com/logos/Logo Sfondo Bianco.png"},{"@id":"https://www.basco-t.com/#/schema/image/1","@type":"ImageObject","contentUrl":"https://www.basco-t.com/api/assets/758ed319-36f2-4869-bc8b-219b24072253","inLanguage":"en-GB","url":"https://www.basco-t.com/api/assets/758ed319-36f2-4869-bc8b-219b24072253"}]}
```

## Sitemap

See the full [sitemap](https://www.basco-t.com/sitemap.md) for all pages.
